Blog

We keep you up to date on the latest tax changes and news in the industry.

Indiana's Tax Hike: Revisiting Historic Bootlegging

As Indiana escalates its cigarette taxes, the state inadvertently rekindles a bygone era of bootlegging. This modern fiscal policy seeks to curb smuggling with stringent new laws, echoing the Prohibition days of raids on moonshiners and racketeers. States such as Indiana raise the cost per pack to enhance public revenue, yet grapple with the specter of further illegal trade.

Nostalgia intertwines with current events, as historical accounts from the mid-1930s highlight operations dismantling bootleg beer and tobacco enterprises. The modern parallel sees interstate roads rife with bargain-hunting smokers evading taxes, reminiscent of past clandestine networks.

Image 1

States like Kentucky and Tennessee offer lessons in contrasts. Kentucky’s minimal cigarette tax creates a thriving black market. Similarly, past hikes in Tennessee spurred tobacco smuggling operations, akin to illicit “beer flats.”

However, the broader picture reveals complexity. A 2018 Johns Hopkins Bloomberg brief explored the fiscal outcomes of states increasing cigarette taxes by over 50 cents. Indiana’s hike in 2007 from 55¢ to 99.5¢ per pack saw a 43% increase in revenue in twelve months, despite smuggling concerns among neighboring states.

Law Enforcement and Legislative Updates

Commencing July 1, Indiana will significantly boost its cigarette tax and enforce new measures:

  • Outlawing bulk out-of-state purchases, converting high-volume imports into felony offenses.

  • Bolstered task forces—involving Excise and state police—scrutinizing shipments at toll booths and storage facilities.

  • Unexpected audits targeting wholesalers and retailers to intercept counterfeit tax stamps.

  • Projected revenue increase: $290 million annually, allocated to public health initiatives.

Indiana's geographical closeness to states with lower taxes like Kentucky heightens the risk of illegal trade. A Tax Foundation report listed Indiana as a top contender for surges in cigarette smuggling post-tax increases.

Image 2

Prospective adaptations loom as Ohio’s potentially contributes to cross-border hassles given its relatively low taxes and dense highway networks. Mackinac Center's 2024 study anticipates nearly 12% of Indiana’s cigarette consumption deriving from out-of-state buys post-tax hike.

Comparative Strategies: Illinois & New York

Illinois:

  • Illinois has elevated its taxes on nicotine products, prompting a surge in smuggling activities as 30% of cigarettes are believed to be illicitly imported.

  • Swift penalties on unstamped packs, ranging from $20-25 for more than nine packets, aimed to curb high-volume illicit trade after a tax increase.

Image 3

New York:

  • Facing one of the highest aggregate taxes, New York grapples with smuggling rates exceeding 50% post recent hikes.

  • Enforcement by the state's Tax Office and the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco & Firearms targets high-volume trafficking with felony charges.

The Historical Roots: Indiana’s Legacy

Indiana’s penchant for circumventing taxes has historical precedence. During the Prohibition era, it was an epicenter for moonshine operations, especially in the southern regions like Lawrence and Dubois counties. Known for transport routes labeled as “Whiskey Roads,” these regions thrived on illicit practices.

Today's contraband moves involve cigarette packs, not homemade liquor, yet the underlying principle remains: navigating legal gray areas using local geography. Former Indiana Excise officer John Halverson acknowledges, “Back then, it was stills in barns. Now it’s cartons in car trunks.”

Public Health or Fiscal Gamble?

Opinions are mixed on the efficacy of these tax policies. Public health proponents argue that rising tobacco costs lead to declining smoking rates, especially among youth and lower socio-economic groups. Mike Seilback of the American Lung Association affirms, “Higher tobacco prices are the single most effective way to reduce smoking.”

Evidence suggests that smuggling levels, though significant, do not negate potential revenue gains if enforcement is robust. Indiana’s 2007 experience saw a dramatic decline in sales but a commensurate rise in revenue.

An Uncertain Outcome

Indiana’s strategy is a high-stakes gamble. Beyond revenue forecasts, the outcome depends on a balance between deterrence and enforcement. Can local vendors adapt? Will modern-day contrabandists outmaneuver authorities? The 1930s’ spirit, it seems, continues to thrive on Indiana's routes. While methods and stakes have evolved, the essence of this age-old conflict remains.

Share this article...

Sign up for our newsletter.

Each month, we will send you a roundup of our latest blog content covering the tax and accounting tips & insights you need to know.

I confirm this is a service inquiry and not an advertising message or solicitation. By clicking “Submit”, I acknowledge and agree to the creation of an account and to the and .

We care about the protection of your data.